Divergence Between the Markets and the Fed

Advertisements

In recent months, the American economy has exhibited some surprising resilience amidst persistent inflationary pressures that have plagued the Federal ReserveEmployment numbers have remained strong, with the housing market showing signs of recovery, leading analysts to increasingly speculate that the U.Smay be on course for a "soft landing.” This term refers to a scenario in which economic growth slows but does not result in a recession, which could be a pleasant surprise for both the markets and policymakers alike.

At the beginning of the year, many Wall Street analysts set a gloomy tone, predicting that a recession would hit the U.Seconomy before long, and that the Fed would soon shift towards rate cuts in the latter half of the yearA brief liquidity crisis in the banking sector added further weight to these concerns

However, as the months have progressed, the employment landscape has shown a remarkable ability to maintain low unemployment rates, and job growth has continued robustlyEven more astonishing is the resilience of the housing market in the face of significant interest rate hikes, which have bolstered equity markets, evidenced by the Nasdaq index soaring nearly 30% in recent months.

The Consumer Price Index (CPI) has shown a downward trend, although the core CPI—which strips out volatile food and energy prices—continues to remain high, fueled in part by strong wage growthConsequently, the Fed remains wary of inflation’s persistence and is anticipated to raise interest rates again in JulyThe general consensus in the market has been that a 25 basis point hike is virtually a given.

Despite the Fed's struggles to fully rein in inflation, a continued uptick in rates could still favor the scenario of a soft landing

While stock market increases in the first quarter may have been primarily driven by hopes of future rate cuts, the continued rally in the second quarter indicates a shift in market sentiment towards a stabilization of the economy, indicating the possibility of a successful soft landing.

A mistaken approach by the Fed in 2021 allowed inflation to ramp up unchecked, leading to an urgent correction in 2022. However, their decisive actions during the recent banking liquidity crisis in 2023 suggest that the central bank’s credibility is on the path to recovery, enhancing the potential for a soft landing.

The divergence in expectations between the Fed and the market surrounds the timeline for future interest rate hikesMany Fed officials maintain projections for two more rate hikes in the second half of the year, while futures markets widely expect July to mark the last increase, with a potential cut before the year's end

This disconnect begs the question: which side will prove to be correct?

The current state of the U.Seconomy demonstrates noteworthy resilience despite the Fed’s aggressive rate hikes over the past yearIn the first quarter of 2023, U.SGDP experienced an annualized growth rate of 2%, and the average growth over the past three quarters has been around 2.6%—considerably exceeding expectationsConsumer spending, which accounts for about 70% of U.Seconomic activity, increased at an annualized rate of 4.2% in the first quarter, representing the highest level observed since Q3 of 2021. The primary drag on economic growth has arisen from investment, which is notably sensitive to rising interest rates, thereby increasing borrowing costs.

Moreover, the U.Slabor market has shown impressive resilience alongside consumer spending

alefox

In June, non-farm payrolls rose by 209,000, a number below the 12-month average, yet reasonably strong given the current economic climate marked by rising interest ratesUnemployment stood at a mere 3.6%, reflecting a monthly decline and indicating a robust labor marketAnalysts at Joaquin Securities have attributed the lower-than-expected job growth to temporary adjustments in sectors like wholesale and retail, suggesting that the labor market will strengthen again post-July as conditions improve.

Historically, periods of recession in the U.Seconomy have consistently been coupled with negative non-farm employment growth and rising unemployment ratesTake, for instance, the early months of 2020, when the COVID-19 pandemic triggered an unprecedented economic downturn, leading to a rapid rise in unemployment rates above 10% amid significant job losses.

Earlier this year, fears of a banking liquidity crisis triggered by the collapse of Silicon Valley Bank loomed, raising concerns over tightening financial conditions and further economic slowdown

This scenario heightened expectations for the Fed to pivot toward rate cuts in the latter half of the yearHowever, markets have demonstrated resilience; the Fed promptly injected liquidity into the banking sector, preventing a broader financial contagionRecent stress tests released by the Fed indicate that major U.Sbanks can endure serious global economic downturns without falling into distress.

The American housing market has also displayed sensitivity to interest ratesAfter a substantial cooling in 2022 followed by significant rate hikes, signs of recovery began to emerge in the second half of the yearNew home sales started to rebound in July 2022, and by May 2023, new home sales had increased by 12.2% month-over-month with a year-over-year growth of 20%.

In June, the Fed adjusted its economic forecasts for 2023, raising its expectations for GDP growth from an earlier estimate of 0.4% to 1% and lowering its unemployment rate prediction from 4.5% to 4.1%. This adjustment indicates a growing confidence from the Fed in the likelihood of a soft landing.

Based on the current state of employment, consumer spending, and the stabilization of the real estate market, signs of an imminent recession appear to be absent

The economic landscape appears to favor a soft landing narrative, which has influenced financial markets; with 10-year Treasury yields rising back above 4%, the S&P 500 has surged nearly 15% since the beginning of the year, and the Nasdaq index has shown an astounding rise of nearly 30%.

The ongoing divergence between market expectations and the Fed’s policy outlook has intensifiedThe resilience of the U.Seconomy allows the central bank to remain focused on combating inflationProjections from June's officials predict that the benchmark interest rate may reach 5.5%-5.75% by the end of the year—an increase of approximately 50 basis points from current levels—suggesting that two more rate hikes could be on the horizon.

However, the gap between market sentiment and the Federal Reserve’s predictions has remained substantial

The CME FedWatch Tool suggests that the central bank may shift to a rate-cutting mode by the end of 2023, which marks a significant ideological riftWall Street appears skeptical of the Fed's forward-looking rate perspective, raising concerns over whether economic conditions will align with these projections.

The Fed’s 2021 decision to delay taking action against surging inflation is a point of criticism; officials believed the inflationary trends were temporary, leading to a failure to promptly adjust their policiesConsequently, after facing ridicule from economists and market participants alike, the Fed had no choice but to enact severe rate hikes in 2022 to address the belated errors, eroding some of its credibility.

Presently, the Fed appears to be adopting a more data-dependent approach, reacting to short-term data changes rather than using proactive strategies to guide interest rate paths

Conversely, the market maintains that continuous rate hikes will inevitably lead to economic contraction and declining inflation, with the expectation of eventually moving toward cuts.

Such significant disparities between market predictions and the Fed’s outlook are rare, which raises the stakes—one side must ultimately be incorrectIf the U.Seconomy sustains its current resilience while inflation remains elevated, markets may soon need to reassess their rate-cutting expectationsPresently, bond and forex markets are sluggish in responding to this possible recalibration, particularly as the dollar has failed to appreciate since the second quarter, exposing foreign currencies to depreciation risks.

Conversely, if both U.Seconomic activity and inflation rapidly decline, holding high interest rates could be impractical, aligning the Fed's policies closer to market expectations.

Overall, current trends favour predictions aligned with the Federal Reserve's forecasts

The strength of the economy and the persistent inflation suggest that inflation may not return to normal levels as swiftly as previously hypothesized.

Wage growth, an immediate concern, contributes significantly to U.Sinflation, derived from four primary components: food and energy prices, goods prices, rents, and service prices—each with respective weightings in the CPIRecently, energy commodities and service costs have seen significant declines, primarily driven by fluctuations in oil pricesFollowing a peak above $120 in mid-2022, WTI crude prices have diminished to around $75, leading energy CPI growth rates to drop sharply from over 41% in June 2022 to -11.7% by May of this year.

Goods prices are also falling as a result of increased interest rates and a deceleration in global economic activity

In fact, the inflation rate for goods in the CPI—excluding food and energy—has declined from 12.3% year-over-year in February 2022 to just 2% in May 2023.

Examining rentals reveals that, despite cooling in the housing market and falling rent prices post-Fed rate hikes in 2022, the existing rent component, which accounts for a significant share of housing inflation, exhibits inertia due to long lease durationsWhile new rents may decline, the rate of adjustment for established rents has been notably slower, evidenced by a year-on-year growth of 8% in May for rent of primary residence CPI.

Ultimately, it is service pricing—largely influenced by wages—that holds the most substantial sway over U.SinflationThe labor market's dynamics, especially following the pandemic, have seen wages rise substantially

For instance, private-sector wages surged to 8.2% in April 2020 but have moderated to a 4.6% growth year-on-year as of June 2023, still exceeding the pre-pandemic average of around 3%.

The dynamics of wage growth are closely tied to labor market conditionsIf demand for labor rises, wages increase; conversely, a decrease in labor supply tends to push wages upwardIn this scenario, the robustness of the U.Seconomy has prevented cooling labor demand from significantly driving wages downAdditionally, the pandemic has left a lasting impact on labor supply, complicating wage contraction more severely than in past cycles.

According to previous estimates from the Fed, non-farm payrolls need to average below 100,000 monthly to achieve a balanced labor marketIn the first half of 2023, the average was 278,000 new non-farm jobs per month, indicating a substantial way to go before equilibrium is reached.

While inflation remains a thorn in the Federal Reserve's side, it is a fortunate nuisance, given the resilience of both the labor market and the U.S

Share this Article